Avatar 2009 vs dances with wolves 1990 movie smackdown. Avatar isnt dances with wolves, its another plot brad. Kevin costners name didnt appear in the closing credits of avatar, but it should have. When a bad kids movie comes out sinbad animated film, monster house people kinda forgive it and forget about it. The illustrated story of the epic film newmarket pictorial moviebooks by kevin costner, michael blake, et al. Dances with wolves thrilled audiences way back in 1990 and made so darn much money precisely because people had forgotten the pleasures of the long narrative, the western genre, and movies that werent special effects schlockfests. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading dances with wolves. When avatar hit theaters, many scoffed that theyd seen the movie the first time, when it was called dances with wolves, ferngully. Michael blake has 44 books on goodreads with 36240 ratings.
James cameron wins avatar plagiarism lawsuit by proving he. How many movies can you think off that dances with smurfs is stealing story, plot, characters, etc. Dances with wolvesis an epic western movie adapted by writer directorstar kevin costner from a novel by michael blake in. Meanwhile, theres a precious glimpse of supernatural season five, righteous zombielandlegion posters, and a fringe storyboard. Pretty much, avatar is dances with wolves plus some amazing special effects, a little postbushera leftism, and a. James cameron admits avatar is dances with wolves in space. Dances with wolves is welldeserving of its seven academy awards.
I got the book because i was interested to see if it explains how john dunbar had become the kind of person that was portrayed so wonderfully by kevin costner in the movie. Dances with wolves is a rare western film that accurately portrays the native american way of life and how it changed with white settlement. In dances with wolves and avatar, kevin costner and james cameron dedicated time and effort to accurately portraying the indigenous groups, the native americans living on the plains and the navi people of pandora, respectively, in term of their language, clothing, and other aspects of daily life. However, the movie was not robbed of the best picture because dances with wolves was clearly superior in terms of filmmaking, thats why it won. Avatar was written by james cameron and is not based on any story. From smalltown oklahoma native to internationally acclaimed actor and musician, wes studi credits his passion and multifaceted background for his powerful character portrayals that forever changed a hollywood stereotype. Its kevin costners best film,for none of his others can beat it. I agreed that its a good movie and all but im sorry, the movie was filled with random killings and fbombs. In the film this is changed to a band of lakota sioux. It was written as a possible source for a screenplay, and was later adapted by the author, and was produced as a film of the same name in 1990 by kevin costner, although there were many differences between the novel and film.
Its about some white missionaries who go to the amazon rainforest to spread the gospel to the natives. Cameron rips off hollywood cliches to the point you could cut and paste dialogue from pocahontas or dances with wolves into avatar without appreciably changing the story. Avatar isnt dances with wolves, its another plot brad ideas. Dances with wolves and avatar are alike in plot and cultural significance. He went on to do humanitarian work, and continued to write. Not soon after, the frontier becomes the frontier no more, and as the army advances on the plains, john must make a decision that will not only affect him, but also the lives of the natives he now calls his people. Dances with wolves tells us the story of a white man who gets acquainted with the sioux, who learns to love and respect them as valuable people with a. It gets you emotionally drawn to the film dances with wolves is the 1990s version of avatar.
Relive the adventure and beauty of the incredible movie, dances with wolves. Avatar is more criticized for the inherent racism in the film, as it is also a white savior film. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Dances with wolves is a critically acclaimed film, but still is a white savior film where indigenous people are unable to save themselves. James cameron combined dances with wolves and star wars in a petri dish, and avatar is. Kevin costner both headlines and directs dances with wolves, the civil warera tale of john. Camerons defense team played dances with wolves in court for judge morrow and then played avatar to show the striking plot similarities the two films shared. Avatar marketed as james camerons avatar is a 2009 american epic science fiction film directed, written, produced, and coedited by james cameron and stars sam. There are currently a few books out based on the movie, but mostly on the art and books for children. Dances with wolves fort sedgewick deleted scene duration. It is a film adaptation of the 1988 book of the same name by michael blake that tells the story of union army lieutenant john j. Even though avatar kind of rips off dances with wolves. The game from ubisoft, with its oftheard promises of being an interactive experience. Joe mentions that adams pilot script for holliston was unoriginal like the movie avatar which is known as having the exact same storyline as dances with wolves.
Avatar had already been compared to dances with wolves prior to the broadcast of dances with smurfs, and james cameron said he welcomed the comparison. Within a few years of his arrival in hollywood, studi caught the attention of the public in dances with wolves. I wont go blow for blow, but watch them back to back and tell me that avatar is not a ripoff of dances with wolves. Nov 04, 2011 conservative columnist jonah goldberg wrote of it as plagiarized political propaganda. In the movie, tom berenger plays an american who is living with the local. Avatar copied dances with wolves this is only a taste of what teenage girls get. Revisiting the white savior complex dances with avatar. James cameron wins avatar plagiarism lawsuit by proving. Pretty much, avatar is dances with wolves plus some amazing special effects, a little postbushera leftism, and a heavy dose of pantheistic creationworship. Cartmans movie prominently features the smurfs, a fictional group of small blue cartoon creatures, which draws a further parallel to the blue alien creatures in avatar. I dont understand why everybody thinks goodfellas better.
Similar but different dances with wolves and avatar are thought to be very different, but they are actually more similar than viewers may realize. Ordered to hold an abandoned army post, john dunbar found himself alone, beyond the edge of civilization. Dances with wolves and avatar 1142 words 5 pages dances with wolves and avatar. When avatar came out in december 2009 many wags quipped that james camerons biggest hit movie of all time, unless you factor in inflation was nothing but ferngully in space. The natives are portrayed as animals that are mystically attached to nature on a distant moon and. Dunbar costner who travels to the american frontier to find a military post and of his dealings with a group.
The film is based off michael blakes book with the same name. James cameron has said that it has some similarities to the emerald forest and at play in the fields of the lord, and that there. Dances with wolves or advanced, postsingularity culture meets humanity. Avatar books based on the movies are coming out soon for. The complete list of sources avatar s accused of ripping off. Movies and books about characters who go native ala. Every single movie, show, cartoon, store, book or anything that is made for teenage girls or teenage boys is completely rejected. Books like avatar 2009 dances with wolves last samurai i just rewatched avatar today and i noticed that each of these movies share the idea of a protagonist seeing another culture, people, etc, as worth admiring and then eventually they join said community despite the overwhelming odds of them being eradicated. Your guide to james camerons many avatar lawsuits, and which. Avatar trailer spoof dances with wolves hd youtube. Indeed, avatar is a great example of what james herrick wrote about in his book, scientific mythologies. The flow of the book is, smooth, for the most part. Free dances with wolves essays and papers 123helpme. Dances with wolves is a 1990 american epic western film starring, directed and produced by kevin costner in his feature directorial debut.
Webb, david webb and dan webb, former principal of john muir high school in pasadena, california. They are essentially the same stories, with the same character arcs and overall themes. How science and science fiction forge new religious beliefs ivp, 2008. Camerons defense team also presented a blockbuster video receipt from march 2 nd 1991, the night cameron first rented dances with wolves. The following constitutes the various aspects of a white savior film according to matthew hughey.
We break down the similarities between the epic movies. There are only spoilers in the last portion of this, starting at 5. Having also read the book,i did feel that the scene in which john dunbar arrives at fort sedgewick,only to find it deserted,needed explanation,so i am glad that this special. Rather than focusing on dances with wolves the entire time the novel involves several different characters from ten bears village and their enemies. Jan, 2010 avatar really tells the same story as movies such as the last samurai, brother bear, and dances with wolveswhere a foreigner has preconceptions about an alien culture, yet upon spending time with them and learning their ways, realizes that his new home is truly the more benevolent, and that his original ways were really inhumane. Theres a serious race debate going on with avatar which ive kinda avoided.
Its kevin costners best film,for none of his others can beat dances with wolves is the 1990s version of avatar. District judge margaret morrow, who yesterday ruled in favor of director james cameron in a lawsuit that alleged he stole the idea for his recordbreaking blockbuster, avatar, from plaintiff gerald morawski, revealed she came to her verdict after camerons attorneys proved that the director actually stole the plot from kevin costners oscarwinning film, dances with wolves. I did make it mainly for those who have watched them both. White fang by jack london, the sight by david clementdavies, the call of the wild by jack london, dances with wolves by mich.
Dances with wolves analysis essays 2123 words bartleby. Dances with wolves is a 1990 american epic western film starring, directed and produced by kevin costner. Socio on avatar, dances with wolves, and the last samurai. Dances with wolves is a 1988 novel written by michael blake. The book plays out differently than i thought it would going in. In dances with wolves john dunbar is a lieutenant in the union army during the civil war. Dec 24, 2009 kevin costners name didnt appear in the closing credits of avatar, but it should have. Avatar was my most personal film, drawing upon themes and.
There are slight changes from my original spoof parody. The writing of michael blake in the novel form of dances with wolves is solid, and it gets the job done, doing an adequate, if not fantastic, job of telling the story of john dunbar and stands with a fist. That means the actors can be hired based strictly on their ability to act, and their bankability, not necessarily their looks, or more to the point their. Eventually, the two men are recognized as part of a tribe, for john the sioux indian tribe and for jake the navi tribe. What is new in the movie is the eyepopping visual effects technology, with its detailed, stunning creation of an alien planet, complete with exotic flora, fauna, and indigenous population with its own language. Adam defends avatar by saying he liked dances with avatar. Socio on avatar, dances with wolves, and the last samurai theothersocio. Dec 30, 2009 james camerons avatar combines these two archetypes in a movie that might be called dances with aliens. More interesting to me is the constant comparisons with dances with wolves. With such a wave of success comes james camerons avatar. For example, in the movies dances with wolves and avatar, john dunbar and jake sully had to learn each tribes way of life, such as their language, hunting, and selfdefense. Not having seen ferngully we couldnt really comment on it, but since then we did manage to see ferngully a 1992 animated movie featuring the voice talents of christian. I enjoyed reading dances with wolves by michael blake the second time around a lot more than the first reading in 2014. In avatar, jake sully sam worthington leaves earth behind in 2154 to jet off to distant pandora, a lushly untamed planet filled with danger and intrigue and populated by an indigenous.
This is a trailer that spoofs avatar with video clips from dances with wolves as the plots from both movies are very similar. Its about a man who joins an indian tribe after he is sent to man an outpost on the frontier. In both avatar and wolves, its not long before the foreign white man takes a liking to the native culture he inhabits. The book s title has nothing to do with wolves apart from the main characters friendship in his loneliness with a wolf he names two socks because of the white colouring on his two front paws and his triumphant dancing in indian style around his camp fire accompanied by. I first saw when it was released in cinemas,in 1991. Victor grech avatar dances with wolves university of malta. I think in the early 60s, and later included in his award winning novel city. Changing from a dignified solider to a sioux warrior in the movie dances with wolves lieutenant john dunbar is a dynamic character. Kevin costner then asked him to write a screenplay for the film based on the novel. The viewer walks away with much more than just having seen a movie. What is the theme of the movie dances with wolves answers. It is a film adaptation of the 1988 book of the same name by michael blake. In a flashback, we learn that he had been hurt and believed that his leg was going to be.
Even though avatar kind of rips off dances with wolves, the smurfs, and black panther, its difficult to not get excited for books that dig into james camerons created world. The movie dances with wolves was a wonderful movie, the kind of movie that rates five stars. Dances with wolves kindle edition by blake, michael. In the novel dances with wolves, dunbar lives among the comanche rather than the lakota sioux.
John dunbar, is a white man who ends up in the wilderness and comes to live with a tribe of comanche, eventually taking on the name dances with wolves. Like those revolutionary westerns directors kept making in the early 70s, or like the later dances with wolves, avatar is camerons lets be fair to the indians movie. In the short time ive had 3d ive managed to acquire the majority of commercially available 3d movies not anaglyph and watched them. Someone needs to show avatar to kevin costner, because i think he may have a really good lawsuit. Big movie with big environmental themes treehugger.
Thievery and survival soon forced him into the indian camp, where he began a dangerous adventure that changed his life forever. She was rescued by the comanche when a different tribe came and attacked her home, killing all of her family, and leaving. Dances with wolves main characters continued stands with a fist independent novel study english 201 stands with a fist is kicking birds adopted daughter. The holy road 2001, blakes sequel novel, takes place 11 years after dances with wolves when white rangers capture stands with a fist and her infant daughter. Camerons exwife, zero dark thirty director kathryn bigelow, who was still married to. The complete list of sources avatars accused of ripping off. If you thought avatar was good and havent seen dances with wolves in a while i highly recommend it. We will analyze our core films and the help to determine if they are guilty of being a white savior film according to hughey. He is known as dances with wolves to them and as time passes he becomes enamored by the beautiful stands with a fist. The plot was nearly identical to the 1990 costner flick. Now that we know avatar s floating mountains were based on chinas. Dances with wolves,movie kevin costners 1990 civil war film about a soldier who bonds with a tribe of native americans. Dances with wolves and avatar have very similar stories.
Both tell stories of colonial invasion, military conquest, and environmental exploitation. Avatar is one of those films one loves or hates with it seems, not a great deal of middle ground. James cameron has said that it has some similarities to the emerald forest and at play in the fields of the lord, and that there is a connection to the film dances with wolves. Kevin costners 1990 film dances with wolves and james camerons 2009 avatar share more than plot, character, and setting. Dances with wolves analysis the movie dances with wolves was produced in 1990 and directed by kevin costner who starred as the main character. Run of the arrow a man called horse avatar film red scorpion. The wordview behind avatar and a christian perspective on.
While avatar has huge flaws in its storytelling including some scenes with very weak dialogue it might have gotten away with it as the audience is perhaps distracted by the bombardment of impressive cgi effects. Books by michael blake author of dances with wolves. The native americans were obviously not thieves or ruthless killers, but were simply misunderstood by their different ways of life and different culture. Dances with wolves 1990 and avatar 2009 filmcan productions.
822 1004 554 955 463 928 1109 134 1101 1087 755 1394 1448 346 1298 1532 1090 1551 1023 1163 944 546 1309 72 736 117 192 1133 647 1540 1056 1468 1310 1452 1015 1201 1109 484 152 1185 427 226